Michelle Martin

Positive reinforcement

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Our new dog is about to start his first obedience training classes, which, if previous experience is any guide, is really a class for me to learn how to get him to do what I want, not so much a class to teach him anything.

Indeed, any learning he does will come from me, not the teacher, and it will come not by way of the dog drawing logical conclusions and feeling an innate sense of satisfaction when confusing and seemingly unrelated things connect and make sense — “When she makes the ‘sit’ sound, I’m supposed to sit!” — but because he will see that when he does a particular thing after a particular cue, good things happen.

In this case, you can read “chicken” or “cheese” for “good things.”

There’s a reason students are advised to bring their dogs to class hungry.

There will likely be many sort-of jokes made about using the same principles of operant conditioning to train spouses and children — “sort-of jokes” because, of course, the same kind of conditioning works on people, too.

When it comes to training dogs, I’m pretty much an all-positive-reinforcement kind of person. No swatting with rolled up newspapers, no yelling or screaming, aside from maybe a genuine yelp if he nibbles on my fingers. Negative reinforcement — punishment — is more likely to confuse the dog and make him want to avoid you.

Which, as we prepare to head into Advent and the holiday season, leads me to look at the way we Catholics sometimes behave when our pews suddenly fill up with unfamiliar faces.

Do we happily make room for people, or do we give the side-eye to the person sitting where we usually sit — in “our seat,” although they have no way of knowing that? Do we say to our neighbor whom we rarely see at Mass, “Great to see you!” or, “It’s been a while, huh?”  Are homilies pitched at a wide audience, or are they aimed at drawing a distinction between the sheep — the “good people,” the ones who are in church every week — and the goats, the sinners who only darken the doors of the church occasionally, maybe only to please relatives or for tradition’s sake?

Because telling someone they aren’t one of the good ones isn’t likely to make them want to come back. It isn’t going to help them feel that they are loved by God, or that they are our neighbors, whom we are to love as we love ourselves.

Better for us to welcome our friends and neighbors to the table than for us to try to make them feel unworthy.

We are all hungry for God, and our hearts, St. Augustine said, are restless until they rest in God.

Topics:

  • family life

​​​​​​​

Advertising