Father John Kartje

October 18: 29th Sunday of Ordinary Time

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Church, state

Is 45:1, 4-6; Ps 96:1, 3, 4-5, 7-8, 9-10; 1 Thes 1:1-5b; Mt 22:15-21

In 16 days our nation will go to the polls. Thus it’s providential that our readings invite us into a serious reflection on how God acts in the world, particularly as it relates to our models of self-governance.

For many people this raises a problematic concern: the mixing of politics and religion, or a failure to respect the “separation of church and state.”

Thomas Jefferson used that phrase in a letter to the Danbury Baptist association in Connecticut in 1802. He wrote that legislatures should “make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, thus building a wall of separation between church and state.”

Jefferson’s primary concern was to ensure that governments would neither force religion upon a population nor prohibit its practice. But for some, the “wall of separation between church and state” has come to mean that religion has no place in the political forum.

From the Catholic perspective, nothing could be further from the truth. Indeed, a recent document from the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, “The Role of the Church in American Political Life,” clearly states that: “Everything, including political life, belongs to Jesus Christ, and so participation in political life belongs to the mission of the Church.”

How could it be otherwise, given Jesus’ frequent interaction with the religious authorities of his day, as well as with Herod, Pilate, and various officers in the Roman army? As we live in the world as Christians, we aspire to love one another as Christ has loved us. This inevitably means that how we exercise our citizenship should be governed by the life Christ calls us to follow.

Furthermore, the church reminds us that the privilege of citizenship carries with it the responsibility of developing a well-formed conscience through the study of church teaching, prayer and seeking holy mentors. The USCCB website is replete with documents and videos treating many of the most pressing social and political issues of the day.

But the call to live as a faith-filled Catholic citizen of the republic is about much more than how you cast your vote on Election Day. Even if your candidate does not win, perhaps especially if they do not win, you are no less called upon to continue publicly living your faith long after the final ballot is cast.

Now consider this call to live as a Catholic citizen in light of this Sunday’s readings. In the first passage, God declares that Cyrus, one of the greatest conquerors and rulers of the ancient world, is doing the bidding of the God of Israel; Cyrus’ great conquests have been the manifestation of God’s own divine will.

Do you truly believe that God is acting so directly in the world today? I fear that the wall of separation between church and state has largely weakened the belief and trust in our God’s ability, or even desire, to be a force in our presence. Such a belief need not mean that God fails to respect our freedom, but it would require a fresh commitment to the reality of grace and its power to influence our minds and hearts.

Nonviolent protests; taking a stand at work for what is right or to defend an abused coworker; making firm, even if extremely unpopular, decisions in raising your family; and so forth — all of these are faith-filled acts of God at work in the world.

And when Jesus declares that we should give to Caesar what is Caesar’s, he is hardly conceding that we should bifurcate our lives and somehow live with one foot in the public square and another in the church. At every moment of your life you are both fully a public citizen and fully a citizen of God’s kingdom.

The latter day Caesars of our world may delude themselves into thinking they own something of ours that is not ultimately from the Lord. But that’s no reason for us to believe them, no matter the cost to ourselves.

When you make your choice on Nov. 3, you will be living proof of Isaiah’s claim about Cyrus and Jesus’ pronouncement about Caesar. There is no wall between church and state, only a threshold.

Topics:

  • scripture

​​​​​​​

Advertising